Replay Andersonville Reviews

We tried 3 different brews. Had the tomato soup w/grilled cheese. Yum!

Adriana and Ricky take such good care of me!! Food and drinks are solid, everyone always seems to be having a good time. A perfect neighborhood bar that treads the line of sports bar and regular hangout.

Cool bar and grill with stand up arcade games.

My gf and I had an amazing time here, incredibly friendly service and the food was delicious. However!! Their bathroom has toilet paper with the roll under and not over. Very close to taking a point off for this grave travesty 🤭

Have been coming here for years (since they opened!) - Consistently good food & great, friendly service that is welcoming to all.

Ricky took great care of us today, very funny guy. Great food and nice atmosphere! Thanks for getting us out the cold!

Great sports bar with really good food and amazing atmosphere. Adrian and the other bartenders have never treated us wrong. I recommend the hot honey mustard wings with their house-made ranch. Also one of the best places to watch a game in Andersonville.

Very good experience here. We went on a Saturday late morning for brunch. The vibe was upscale sports bar (many monitors with various games playing). The music they had on was upbeat but pretty loud. Vast beer selection and good Bourbon selection. The food was really good. Service was fine. Our waiter was nice but I think he may have been hungover or otherwise not feeling well. The customers who came in were varied but there was a definite LGBTQ vibe. The various arcade games were free to play and that was really fun. Would definitely go again.

Free video games while you are eating and drinking.

Not as many games as the other replay locations but still great atmosphere and long beer list! They had a lot of fun board games too here and that was very fun!

I came for brunch on the patio yesterday and really enjoyed the experience. I was looking at the menu posted outside as I had never been there, and the host rushed out with a brunch menu and welcomed me to sit. I ordered two eggs, ham, biscuit and a side salad. It was honestly the best breakfast I've had! Great service, and great vibe.

Awesome location for brunch or just breakfast. I had the pleasure of meeting Mark, the owner, who was coincidentally enjoying brunch. You really must try the Chicken and Waffles—they're fantastic. The dish features a generous, tender, and juicy chicken breast topped with a light white sauce and a charming eye-shaped garnish. The waffles are thick and moist, perfectly complementing the meal. We also ordered a Greek Omelette with added avocados, which was delightful. Our table was by an open window, offering a lovely outside view alongside perfect weather. To top it all off, we treated ourselves to some champagne with bubbles—an enjoyable luxury at a very reasonable price.

What a nice surprise! We came across this place when traveling didn't expect the gourmet type food we had! Service was great! I had Brussels sprouts for app and the berry burger with ricotta cheese! Fabulous!!

10/10 would recommend! Amazing food and good beer list. Everyone I was with loved the cocktails too. And big shout out to Josh our server. We asked for our the alcohol and food to be in seperate checks and unintentionally made it very confusing and he got it sorted for us with a smile on his face. Everyone was very friendly!

An Andersonville staple. The cubano sandwich is the best I’ve had in the city and their outdoor patio is perfect for an outdoor lunch, dinner, or drink. Their nachos are delicious too!

Food was great and Caleb was so attentive, welcoming, and a fantastic server. Would definitely come back again!!

Went here for post-Hollywood Beach drinks and hangs for pride month, and it was a perfect vibe. Erin is one of the best servers I've ever had!

It is so cool , I like the vibes 😁

Imon is by far the best server I have had. I frequent many of the restaurants in Andersonville and I must say Imon is Awesome! Her happy demeanor is everything on top of her great service! I will be back and requesting Imon!

The server Imon is excellent! She makes the restaurant shine! She is attentive, proactive in knowing guest needs and wants. She is always smiling and positive. Her menu knowledge is impressive and her suggestions are always on point. She is beyond exceptional! She is the reason I became a regular at Replay. Thank you Imon! We appreciate you!

June 4th 6-7ish PM. Our server rocked! I just wanted to make sure he got his props because I forgot to get his name. Super nice and took good care of my friend and I. Whoever he was, thank you!

nice place friendly staff food and service was good I recommend it

Excellent as usual, food is always amazing, staff are friendly and helpful. Love this place

Love the appetizers and drinks Try the quesabirria tacos-wish they add a little more meat but overall good spot for food and drinks

Love every Replay location, first time visiting this place and as a young girl in her 20’s I can say this is a very nice welcoming environment on a Friday night. Our bartenders were very friendly and aware of all their patrons as well as the fella asking for drinks faster than we could down them. I appreciate our bartenders awareness and ability to comprehend a situation that with alternative company could have easily gone sour, the attention from a barkeeper, their awareness and prioritization of patrons shows their understanding of guests and situations and makes me feel 20x more confident in returning to this location.

Often times I've eaten here and it's been, ya know, bar food...which is fine. However, I stopped in so could I grab dinner and play a few video games and was very surprised with the figgy burger. Try it out. I'll come back for it.

What a fantastic restaurant! The food is both delicious and plentiful. We visited for lunch on St. Patrick's Day and had a wonderful experience. We'd definitely go back. Everything, from the food to the service, was top-notch. We tried their special St. Patrick's Day offerings: green eggs and ham with pesto eggs, and the classic Irish corned beef sandwich – every bite was a delight. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was amazing. A very comfortable and welcoming place where you can hang out and enjoy your time. Thank you, Replay!

I'm there weekly, but a 1/2 lb. burger is just too big for me. Other bars in Andersonville have more variety, but the staff is having fun, and their brunch is great.

We love Tuesday Loteria so much! We also like to come here to see soccer matches on TV, and enjoy the patio in the summer.

Loteria was an absolute great time!! First time playing and the hosts were amazing! Great Tuesday night atmosphere. The girls preforming read people to filth and it was amazing. They had a great vibe & filthy sexy saunter. Extremely honest and fun hosts.

Friendly, great service and nice atmosphere!

Wonderful atmosphere! Great drinks!

My husband and I just had our anniversary dinner at Replay, where we had delicious food as always and amazing service from James.

Great food and AMAZING service! Fast, friendly, and decently priced. Talked to the manager, Connor, too, and he made us feel very welcomed! Great to have another friendly establishment in the neighborhood we can visit! Will definitely be coming back!! ♥️

Arcade games

Always have a great experience here. The staff is super helpful and the drinks are tasty. The food is always great too. Love the Buffalo chicken wrap, chicken tenders, Buffalo egg rolls, and fried pickles!

Replay was such a great time, I reserved a table for Saturday evening to celebrate my boyfriends birthday. I had to alter the amount of guests a few times and replay was super Accommodating. Our server Derek was very kind and attentive to our table. (:

Veg Nachos 👌🏼 tater tot nachos 🤤 and it’s fun to go during football games. They have a great patio too!

Love this place. Good food. Great times and memories for families before a certain hour. I wish they’d rotate the menu a little more, but consistently is good too. Thanks for existing, Replay 😀

Have been enjoying the enlarged outdoor seating at Replay. The staff are friendly and the food and drinks are great. 2024- James was a great server . Loved the food and birthday dessert.

Amazing Olde Fashioneds! And free games! The food is really good too.

The Birria quesadilla was so good! All the food was great. And you guys have the best server in the area employed there Tylin ❤️ I can't wait to visit again

My husband and I just moved close by and came to Replay for date night. The drinks were nice and strong and food and service were amazing! Corey was really friendly and made sure we had everything we needed. We will definitely be back!

Very good menu and the food was great. The prices are very high, but that is a reflection on the economy. The service was excellent, topping off drinks and making sure everything was good.

Amazing food and cocktails

All the games are free I really liked it. Nice people working here. Chill vibes.

Visited with a friend while on vacation. Black Manhattan and Old Fashioneds were amazing. Tater tots and crispy cauliflower with curry dipping sauce: so so good. Service was wonderful when one item came out a little undercooked. I highly recommend this place. The food and service were excellent!

Great place to eat and play old retro video games. The burger was delicious and juicy 😋

I love this place. Where else can you get a full service menu, a bar with great beer and bourbon selections, and for dessert decapitate someone while playing Mortal Kombat? Everything I’ve ever eaten here is great. Brunch, salads, buffalo chicken egg rolls, nachos, cheese curds, pesto chicken wrap, burgers, etc. good portions tastefully presented. The service is quick and efficient as well. They make one of the better old fashioneds in the city - always with a big cube. Love the credit card machines that come to your table instead of the typical dreadfully long wait to pay. There is also a great outside seating area that is very dog friendly. This place is tops in my book. Flawless Victory!

Such a fun place! Loved the atmosphere with all the retro games to play. Servers were super nice, just a little slow on getting us new drinks. (It was very busy so im not mad about it!!!) Dont even get me started on the cheese curds and birria tacos. They were insanely delish!!! Great place (:

My first time here is was amazing, my servers name was Ella, I believe… anyways, she was so professional and friendly, so me being from Indiana, I promised I would come back here. I’m here now, and Connor is my bartender, and it proves to show that I made the right choice- the service here is welcoming and fun- I will be coming back again for a 3rd time- and I hope the staff is the same!

Fun environment. Good beer selection

Imon is an excellent server. She is friendly, beautiful inside and out. She is on point. Request her when eating there. She's everything!!! She's it. Period!! She made my experience positive, comfortable and she made me feel welcomed. Imon you rock lady! Keep doing your thing! Peace and respect!

Great patio seating. Wonderful staff.Blake, Derrick and Tylin were all terrific. 4/5 - Wonderful dining experience. Our server, Haven, was super nice. Zach and August were also delightful.

Amazing food I enjoyed the arcade machines I got 3rd place on Galaga I think it’s a one in a kind place I would suggest you visit

This place has amazing food and a welcoming arcade bar vibe. We love it for something for casual but also with a great menu and atmosphere. Highly recommend the nachos and the ice cream cookie skillet!!

The food here is surprisingly good. The wait staff and bartenders are exceptionally cool. We always have a good time and great burgers.

I've got a teen, so if course he loves coming here and playing the retro video arcade games for free, and I've always liked their burgers. But I recently had they're fried chicken there and BAM!, as they say. It was REALLY good! So I already had them at 5 stars, but they still went up in my book.

consistent

We frequently come to Replay for their Tuesday night BYOBeans Drag Loteria. The drinks are delicious and good quality food. All the staff is friendly and attentive. Super unique and fun night!